The History of First United Methodist Church of Fredonia
We got our start in 1811, when "circuit rider" Elijah Metcalf rode into town on horseback and met with three couples. That group met in homes and grew, until the first meeting house was built in 1822 near the present Saint Joseph's Church on Main Street. The congregation continued to flourish, and in 1839, a more imposing structure was built at the corner of Center and Barker Streets. This was torn down in the 1940's. An interesting display of artifacts and our history is located in the present office area.

Membership continued to increase, and a more desirable location was sought. The present property at 25 Church Street was purchased, and during 1868-1869, a red brick church was erected by our 140 members for a cost of $30,000. On December 21, 1922, our red brick church was destroyed by fire, and work began the following Spring to construct our English Neo-Gothic-style edifice, costing $121,000 (its value today is over two million dollars).

In 1956, a campaign to raise $165,000 was successful, and resulted in our building a modern education wing. That mortgage-burning and dedication took place during our sesquicentennial celebration in 1961. In 1970-1971, a major renovation of the sanctuary, office, heating system, and kitchen occurred, and was topped off by the dedication and inaugural recital of our new Schlicker pipe organ.

Link to more Fredonia History
Fredonia Chamber of Commerce